Learners will be able…
… to identify strong arguments of someone with an opposing view to their own.
... to examine reasons for and against a certain argument.
… to get acquainted with justifying a certain aspect, find arguments to support a view different than theirs.
… to reflect how this is connected to the democratic method.
- 40 minutes
- At least 6 people
- Pen and paper (optional)
- Divide the learners into two groups. Present the learners with a current relevant controversial topic. Group A is going to argue for and group B argue against this topic.
- Give the groups 10 minutes to prepare their arguments and non-negotiable points on the subject. Group A presents their arguments first (3 minutes), then group B (3 minutes). After that group A gets to counter-argue (5 minutes), as well as group B (5 minutes). Group A presents their closing argument with 3 non-negotiable points (2 minutes), followed by group B (2 minutes).
- Now switch groups (therefore, all learners in group A now argue against the topic and all learners in group B now argue for the topic). The whole class must then come to an agreement and find common ground.
- Discuss the experience.
- Did they manage to agree in the end?
- Which arguments did they find more compelling and why?
- Did the end decision skew into one side or the other?
- What do they attribute that to?